Home / Religion / Why does Republicans’ Outrage on the Pope Reminds One of Henry VIII?

Why does Republicans’ Outrage on the Pope Reminds One of Henry VIII?

Henry VIII’s love for Catholicism during his early years was undeniable but when in May of 1533, his love life collided with the religious dictum of his time that flowed from the Church in Rome, his opposition to the Pope and the Roman Church was fierce.  For a simple belief in Papal authority, hundreds and thousands were burnt alive, tortured in the most unbelievable ways.  If belief is predicated on faith, then how could it take a u-turn so terribly inhuman?  Because belief is never sincere.  It is a prejudice in action.

During his US visit, the Pope talked of many issues like immigration, Climate change, violence and guns, and compassion.  Suddenly, these have rattled the Republicans.  For the Christian right wing, Climate Change is no longer a simple issue of planet’s survival but that of “faith”.  That is why it seems rather incredulous when Rick Santorum reprimands the Pope to keep to his job in a typical Henry VIII’s style.

“The church has gotten it wrong a few times on science, and I think we probably are better off leaving science to the scientists and focusing on what we’re good at, which is theology and morality.”

If Climate Change was merely an issue of contribution to the planet’s survival – conservation, environment, and science – then it wouldn’t be central to the “faithful”.  Everyone would have approached it differently.  It is the ‘Rick Santorums’ who have shaped Climate into an object of faith, and then chided the faith’s keeper to stay away.

Have things changed any since Henry VIII?

Belief is merely a convenient way to propagating prejudices.  Henry VIII and Thomas Cromwell used it in ways that their society allowed – torture, burnings, beheadings – to further their own prejudices.  Rick Santorum and senators like James Inhofe do it in their ways using what they have available to them in today’s time.

The Pope, however, is a convenient ball to play around with, in this game.  Not that I am advocating Papal infallibility.  Far from it.  I maintain that Roman Church is nothing more than an extension of the Roman Empire.  Same core, same soul, same decadence and same aggression.  Just the means changed.  Christ was a more potent mascot and ruse to make the crimes toward and genocides of almost every indigenous population look righteous.  If Christ was what he is supposed to be, then he was crucified, tortured, beheaded, skinned alive for last 2000 years in the most terrible ways in every nook and corner of every continent, in his own name!

My entry point is the unchanging face of faith.  A faith that is no more than a facade of religiosity. Passed off as devotion, it is nothing like that.  If someone is devoted to Pope, then he can’t be a “have-some, throw-some” authority.  Would he?

What is true of the Pope is true of every religious symbol.  And it is not related to just Catholics.  It is true of all believers of every kind.  For belief is a reflection of personal prejudices.  It has no significance beyond one’s mind and conditioning.

When such politically motivated prejudices start dictating an entire nation’s direction – not just in religion, but in things like education, science, environment and basic life itself, then things can take a downward spiral that is hard to predict.  Henry VIII’s dance of politics, prejudices and religion threw up terrible nightmares like Cromwell and others, but it took mass and ruthless bloodshed by Queen Mary to help everyone realize how badly it had gone wrong.  Should it take an equivalent of a “Bloody Mary” for this generation to realize this?!




Get Drishtikone's Profound Fix

Subscribe to get our latest content by email.

Powered by ConvertKit
A heartfelt NAMASTE! We hope you are enjoying our direct, honest, well-researched posts on topics of immense importance for India and the world! We don't mince our words and don't write general wishy-washy stuff. We go to the heart of the issue and look it in the EYE! Write to me at desh.kapoor@gmail.com and let me know how we can improve!

About Desh Kapoor

The panache of a writer is proven by the creative pen he uses to transform the most mundane topic into a thrilling story. Desh - the author, critic and analyst uses the power of his pen to create thought-provoking pieces from ordinary topics of discussion. He writes on myriad interesting themes. Read the articles to know more about his views and "drishtikone".

Check Also

Panama Papers

Detailed Story of the Panama Papers: What are they are Who are Involved?

shares   Panama Papers are everywhere.  In every country, so many skeletons are tumbling out …

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Why does Republicans’ Outrage on the Pope Reminds One of Henry VIII?"

Notify of

M Raghavan
M Raghavan
October 8, 2015 9:50 am

Protestant Christian culture in the USA has always been a strange bedfellow to how Americans view themselves. It is this weird cocktail of religion disguised as patriotism which the conservatives have been using as a means to selling a oligarchy form of world domination as Capitalism and Democracy.