Political correctness is shrill these days. The faux morality on display is created by media. Media, which wants attention, even when there is not enough merit, plays up sides and two positions. This or That. There are no greys and there are no go-betweens. There is no such thing as a “Complicated situation”. In the world of hashtag moral stands of public, we have everything complicated. From relationships to jobs to pets. But our stands are stark.
The Phony Cacophony of Our Hashtag Morality #VKSingh Click To TweetGeneral VK Singh recently said – using a colloquial way of speaking to explain his point of how something that was an issue between two families had been transformed by the media into a “Caste War” and blamed the Central Government for it. How can any random incident – however gruesome – can be just shoved down the Central Government’s throat? This is what he said –
“Kabhi sthaniya ghatnaon ka sarkar se talluk mat rakhiye. Uske upar inquiry chal rahi hain. Parivaron ke beech mathbhed tha.. voh mathbhed kis roop mein parivartit hua, kahan par intazamiyan ka failure hain, administration ka? Uske bad voh sarkar ke upar aata hain (Never associate local incidents with the Central Government. There is an inquiry going on. There was a dispute between families. The dispute…how did it turn out…where did the arrangements fail, the administration? After all this, it falls upon the Central Government). To har cheez par, ki wahan par pathar maar diya kutte ko to, sarkar jimmewaar hai. Aisa nahi hai. (For everything…like if somebody throws a stone at a dog, then the Central Government is responsible…it is not like that)”
For this remark – there is a hue and cry in India. Suddenly, the political parties want the Union Minister to resign. Over what? A remark that is simply colloquial in nature. Yes, it can be construed anyway including the one that these politically correct folks are suggesting. But isn’t it upon the intelligent and the educated who know the person uttering these remarks has been the chief of the one of finest institutions that India has today and would hardly have been a bigot himself – to assuage the issues that some vested folks may rake up?
We are all human beings and all have our moments and lapses. If we have to latch onto everything that a person says and play that up to a point where it covers the whole days news cycle and the activists – who pretend they are in their vocation out of conviction of their personal morality – keep shouting hoarse knowing the truth fully well, then something is terribly wrong.
Outrage is not justice. Shouting has nothing to do with facts. And, a twitter trend can be manufactured!
In a country where someone like Netaji had his life and death completely falsified with no question whatsoever. Where someone like Lal Bahadur Shastri – the Prime Minister of the country – was assassinated on a foreign soil without any investigation or question from any quarter. In that country, we have morality of people getting all riled up. Why? Because an ex-Army Chief uses a colloquial manner of speaking.
Have we lost it? Honestly. In this day and age of fast lives, where the deadlines cannot be met at work, where the kaam-wali bai at home is a constant problem, where roads aren’t exactly easy to drive back and forth on, where relationships are becoming more and more complex. In that society, we have time for making national issues out of a “manner of speak”?
Sometimes I do wonder if the amplification of our voices that betray raw and tribal emotions by social media has just created a society of chaotic noise? Are we now defined by our noise or our sagacity? For, the cacophony of faux morality by the activist lay man and woman has no time for contemplation. It wants to feed the next twitter trend and define the daily news cycle.
I so agree with you. I am not happy with what the general said but twisting everything to suit a particular agenda is the game that seems to be going on.
Hey Mridula – I agree the General could have been more careful, but its a very common manner of speak anywhere in North. So to use and twist it was unnecessary. Its just sad.
Sometimes (or rather most of the times) I do think that most of whom we call ‘elite’ in our Indian society have lost it, lost it completely. The absurd levels to which they will go in the name of stupidly shallow political correctness is mindboggling. I can only pity them. Really.
Hey Beloo – concur. COmpletely lost it! We are becoming a society if anyone even utters a Muhawara we will see communal feelings. Thank God Kabir and Ghalib are dead or they would have had been the most heckled guys! 😛
Comments, counter-comments, illogical comments, irrational comments – That has become the face politics recently. While there are things to take care of, politicians are busy making Stupid comments, and their own Specialist comments over other poiticians’ comments. It’s all about comments I guess. Someday, someone in politics might actually do something really good than simply make comments, till then let’s amuse ourselves with these political viral comments.
KK – it is in our culture to use different examples. We have been a dialectic culture in the way we have used language and writing. But look at what we have become now. Sad.
Amidst the fabricated twitter trends, moulded truth and havoc creating news bulletins, what ultimately survives, is a complete chaos. Nothing is extracted out of nothing. A hullabaloo of thoughts from the gang of opportunists, who lead a brainless stupid mob.
Great thoughts. Thanks for sharing. 🙂
Thanks, Sangeeta! “Gang of opportunists” – thats the right phrase for them 🙂
The paid media is working full time to create sensation out of nothing and blame central Govt. Twitter trends can be bought and it means nothing. Media houses should be held responsible when they do wrong like they did in Jasleen Kaur, Rothak sisters cases.
Twitter trends in India are specifically bought! After all the India head of Twitter is a self-professed avowed anti-Modi guy. So they are being manufactured! 🙂
I am just sick and tired of what the mass media is doing these days. And twitter really takes the cake. Every statement is twisted for more TRPs, RTs and controversy. It has put me off news now. Nicely written.
Same here, Rachna! Its very difficult to even listen to some “debate” without cringing at the utter nonsense of the anchor and/or the debaters! Neurotic elites!
Sad sad situation with media these days. We don’t need any outside party to malign and divide India, some politicians and our media is doing it for them.
Exactly! No one gives a damn about the country. They are doing all this purely to score political points!
It’s not a matter of a few words or an occasional lapse which people will gladly forget. When there is a pattern people are quick to see through that too.
Pattern? like Admiral Sushil Kumar talked of when he was all angry about “persecutions of Christians”? Of course what he saw as a “pattern” turned out to be RANDOM petty crimes! Lets not create a Us -vs-Them just to hit on a certain group politically.
I agree with your point of view. But thing is, the people in power should be careful about their “choice of words” especially when everybody out there to catch the minute slips. we know media is Anti-Modi for obvious reasons. How could #VKSingh be so careless?? Didn’t he know that Media will twist his words? At this time silence and a fake sympathy works best!!
Opponents will pick on anything to raise a hue and cry but those in responsible positions should mind their words.